Long Island Logo

Bay Shore, NY

3 Multi Families

$275,000 - $534,900

20 Condos

$80,000 - $584,999

182 Single Families

$75,000 - $3,995,000


Homes For Sale in Bay Shore, NY

205 homes for sale

$424,444
$361,549
$349,450
$428,988
$319,000
$376,300

The hamlet's name has changed several times. Early European settlers referred to the place as Penataquit and, earlier, Awixa; both names were used by the Native American Secatogue tribe. By the early 19th century it was renamed Sodom. When and why the name was changed to Sodom remains a mystery. In 1842 it was changed to Mechanicsville, then back to Penataquit in 1849. The name Penataquit proved...

Learn more about Bay Shore

11706

Local Info

23,582
$47,796.00
More Local Info

New Single Family Homes for Sale in Bay Shore, NY

New Listing
New Listing

$1,125,000
Single Family
Posted a moment ago
122 Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 Home For Sale - MLS #2972181
5,900 sq. ft.
1.77 acres

Renovated 7 Bedroom, 6.5 Bathroom 1912 Bay Front Colonial On Penataquit Point " My Fair Lady" Sweeping Water Views, Renovated Kitchen, Great Room For Cozy Mornings Or Lively Parties. Spacious Master...

Read More

New Listing
New Listing

$309,990
Single Family
Posted 1 day ago
1364 Lombardy Blvd, Bay Shore, NY 11706 Home For Sale - MLS #2972050
9,148 sq. ft.

Completely Renovated Ranch In Brightwaters Farm Area Of Bayshore. Everything Is New. New Kitchen, New Bath, New Siding, New Windows, Fenced Yard. Just Move Right In!



New Listing
New Listing

$359,900
Single Family
Posted 1 day ago
71 Bailey Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 Home For Sale - MLS #2971882
0.59 acres

Totally Renovated House. Perfect For First Time Home Buyers



New Listing
New Listing

$848,875
Single Family
Posted 1 day ago
17 Angela Ln, Bay Shore, NY 11706 Home For Sale - MLS #2971783
0.56 acres

Offered In Value Range $739,000-$848,875 . Fabulous Saxon Cove Community With Private Boat Dockage Near Bay And Private Small Island. This Entertainer's Delight Has A Gracious Dining Room; Upscale...

Read More

New Listing
New Listing

$75,000
Single Family
Posted 2 days ago
Bay Shore, NY 11706 Home For Sale - MLS #2971659
0.52 acres

Short Sale Subject To Third Party Approval.



New Condos for Sale in Bay Shore, NY

New Listing
New Listing

$495,000
Condo
Posted 7 days ago
31 Joyces Way, Bay Shore, NY 11706 Condo For Sale - MLS #2970267
2,200 sq. ft.
6,098 sq. ft.

Bright, Spacious & Meticulous Sun Drenched Townhouse Set On Large Corner Property.This Home Features Vaulted Ceilings,Living Rm W/Fireplace & Skylight,Den W/ Fireplace,Eik W/Sliders To Outside...

Read More

$539,000
Condo
Posted 20 days ago
162 Boathouse Ln, Bay Shore, NY 11706 Condo For Sale - MLS #2966992
2,850 sq. ft.
3,049 sq. ft.

Easy Living In This Spacious, Diamond Townhouse In Gated Sunscape South. Updates Include Paint, Hi-Hat Lighting, Hardwood Floors, New Baths, Plantation Shutters, And California Closets. Close To...

Read More

$399,000
Condo
Posted 21 days ago
5 Cedar Ridge Ln, Bay Shore, NY 11706 Condo For Sale - MLS #2966856
2,100 sq. ft.
2,178 sq. ft.

This Is A Large And Lovely 2 Bedroom Morgan Model, 2 And 1/2 Bath Condo Which Boasts Large Rooms, Livingroom W/Fireplace, Ground Floor Patio And Wonderful Balcony Off The En Suite Master. Eat In...

Read More

$80,000
Condo
Posted 21 days ago
15 Hemlock Dr, Bay Shore, NY 11706 Condo For Sale - MLS #2966849
871 sq. ft.

Corner Unit Spacious Condo Exclusive A Must See. Lihp Grant Comes With The Unit. Must Be First Time Home Buyer. Grant Money Available.



$510,000
Condo
Posted 25 days ago
205 Captains Way, Bay Shore, NY 11706 Condo For Sale - MLS #2966204
4,356 sq. ft.

Priced To Sell This Week!! Sought After Location!! Tucked Away And Close To Marina. Quiet Private Setting!. New Siding, Heat, Ac, Led Lighting, Kitchen Cabinets,Wood Floors, Deck, Updated Kitchen And...

Read More

New Multi Family Homes for Sale Bay Shore, NY

New Listing
New Listing

$275,000
Multi-Family
Posted 6 days ago
Bay Shore, NY 11706 House For Sale - MLS #2970891
2,174 sq. ft.
5,227 sq. ft.

Opportunity To Own A Two Family Home. Great To Live In One And Rent One! Bones Of The House Are Great!



$534,900
Multi-Family
Posted 4 months, 25 days ago
1061 Cassel Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 House For Sale - MLS #2933017
3,600 sq. ft.
0.45 acres

Gigantic Home In West Islip School District Wood Floors Thru Out Fenced 1/2 Acre Lot. Everything Well Maintained And Updated 2 Decks Possible Rental Income With Proper Permits. Workshop In Basement,...

Read More

$319,000
Multi-Family
Posted 6 months, 29 days ago
1309 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 House For Sale - MLS #2915665
4,356 sq. ft.

Opportunity 2 Family. 3/4 Br, 2 Bath, 2 Living Rooms, 2 Dr's, Full Basement, Large Fully Fenced Private Yard. Close To Rail Road And Major Highways.



Bay Shore Services

Looking for rental agencies, movers, mortgage brokers, or contractors in Bay Shore? Conveniently find local businesses who can help you with fixing your house, advise you on legal issues, home appraisals, and more!

Browse Bay Shore Services

Newest Listings