{site.name} Logo

Bay Shore, NY

14 Multi Families

$169,990 - $5,000,000

20 Condos

$40,000 - $469,000

342 Single Families

$9,000 - $3,199,500


Homes For Sale in Bay Shore, NY

377 homes for sale

$154,000
$232,529
$249,990
$319,149
$309,900
$646,834

The hamlet's name has changed several times. Early European settlers referred to the place as Penataquit and, earlier, Awixa; both names were used by the Native American Secatogue tribe. By the early 19th century it was renamed Sodom. When and why the name was changed to Sodom remains a mystery. In 1842 it was changed to Mechanicsville, then back to Penataquit in 1849. The name Penataquit proved...

Learn more about Bay Shore

11706

Local Info

23,582
$47,796
More Local Info

New Single Family Homes for Sale in Bay Shore, NY

New Listing
New Listing

$260,000
Single Family
Posted a moment ago
81 Oakdale St Bay Shore NY 11706 Home foreclosure - MLS #2497362
0.36 acres

Expanded Ranch With Loads Of Potential. Master Bedroom W/Bath, Wood Floors,Full Finished Basement,Den W/Fp,Fdr, Eik. Too Much To List! Taxes Not Verified Yet.



New Listing
New Listing

$275,000
Single Family
Posted a moment ago
1557 Baldwin Blvd Bay Shore NY 11706 Home for sale - MLS #2497254
10,018 sq. ft.
0.23 acres


New Listing
New Listing

$499,000
Single Family
Posted a moment ago
49 Lakeside Ln Bay Shore NY 11706 Home for sale - MLS #2497118
2,000 sq. ft.

Spectacular All Season Waterview Ranch, End Unit, Granite Eik, Marble Bath In Mst. Bedroom Suite, 2nd Bedroom, Full Bath, Laundry, Formal Din. Rm., Oversized Brick Patio, New Roof, New Cac, Private...

Read more

New Listing
New Listing

$319,000
Single Family
Posted 1 day ago
1442 Manor Ln Bay Shore NY 11706 Home for sale - MLS #2497015
1,532 sq. ft.
0.28 acres

Beautiful Ranch, Open Floor Plan,Eat In Kitchen With Sliding Glass Doors To The Deck And Yard.Den With Fireplace. Part Basement, Near Parkways And Shopping.



New Listing
New Listing

$279,999
Single Family
Posted 3 days ago
159 Missouri Ave Bay Shore NY 11706 Home for sale - MLS #2496734
7,405 sq. ft.


New Condos for Sale in Bay Shore, NY

New Listing
New Listing

$469,000
Condo
Posted 3 days ago
46 Doral Ln Bay Shore NY 11706 Condo for sale - MLS #2496533

Mst.Suite W/Full Ba On 1st Fl.Custome Expanded Lr,New Custom Flr To Ceiling Stone Fpl(Gas) In Lr. End Unit.24/7 Guarded Gat.



New Listing
New Listing

$85,000
Condo
Posted 13 days ago
55 Pinebrook Pl Bay Shore NY 11706 Condo for sale - MLS #2493660
846 sq. ft.

Mint 1 Bedroom Co. All New Interior Includes New Kitchen Cabinets/Appliances/And Corian Counter Tops. New Carpeting Throughout. Can Rent To Buy If Qualified



$419,000
Condo
Posted 1 month, 5 days ago
9 Oakmont Ln Bay Shore NY 11706 Condo for sale - MLS #2486781

Beautifully Renovated 3 Bedroom Home With 2.5 Baths. Master Bedroom With Walk In Mahogany California Closet & Large Master Suite Bath. Home Is In Diamond Condition. So If You Don't Want To Lift A...

Read more

$385,000
Condo
Posted 1 month, 8 days ago
16 Doral Ln Bay Shore NY 11706 Condo for sale - MLS #2485889


$148,000
Condo
Posted 1 month, 11 days ago
115 Newbrook Ln Bay Shore NY 11706 Condo for sale - MLS #2485065

Updated Sunlit Corner Unit New Kitchen With Stainless Appliances,Newly Painted,Hdw Floors And New W/W,Crown Moldings,Spacious Rooms,Heating Unit Less Than 1 Yr Old,Cac,Laundry Room,Tennis Court &...

Read more

New Multi Family Homes for Sale Bay Shore, NY

$295,000
Multi-Family
Posted 16 days ago
64 Park Ave Bay Shore NY 11706 House for sale - MLS #2492808
0.25 acres


$375,000
Multi-Family
Posted 1 month, 5 days ago
62 Park Ave Bay Shore NY 11706 House for sale - MLS #2486496
1,780 sq. ft.
0.30 acres

Investor Legal 2 Consider Adding Adjacent Income Properties To Your Portifilo.56 Park & 54 Park. Walk To Train Station.Main St, Fire Island Ferries



$295,000
Multi-Family
Posted 1 month, 15 days ago
25 1st Ave Bay Shore NY 11706 House for sale - MLS #2484071
9,148 sq. ft.

Legal 2 Family, With 2.5 Car Detached Garage, Excellent Investment Opportunity. Charmed Turn Of The Century Victorian In The Heart Of Bay Shore New Windows, Updated Heating System, Many Updates, Well...

Read more

$375,900
Multi-Family
Posted 1 month, 17 days ago
Bay Shore NY 11706 House for sale - MLS #2483414
0.38 acres

Legal 3 Family. Close To Railroad, Town, Bay Shore Marina, Ymca, Churches. Apartments: 3 Bedrooms W/Fbth, 1 Bedroom W/Fbth And 1 Bedroom W/Fbth, Plus Garage. Taxes W/Star $12,220.14



$5,000,000
Multi-Family
Posted 1 month, 18 days ago
69 Lawrence Ln Bay Shore NY 11706 House for sale - MLS #2482975
7,000 sq. ft.
1.76 acres

Spectacular Bay Front English Tudar Estate W Guest Cottage, One Of The Few Remaining Jewels On The Great South Bay. This Natural Peninsula Delivers Panoramic Views Of The Bay, Light House And Bridge....

Read more

Bay Shore Services

Looking for rental agencies, movers, mortgage brokers, or contractors in Bay Shore? Conveniently find local businesses who can help you with fixing your house, advise you on legal issues, home appraisals, and more!

Browse Bay Shore Services

Newest Listings